Missing action codes

[mikeinnc]

Referring to my previous post, it looks like probably all the X10 \'All On\' and \'All Off\' codes are swapped. I have changed my X10 light from house-code A4 to C3 and changed all the response codes accordingly. However, I still need to use the C \'All On\' response to turn the lights off! 

I realise that X10 isn\'t flavour of the month, but where it exists, it can still be useful as I am proving. Can this anomaly be investigated, please? I would assume it could be corrected in a future firmware update?

[slychiu]

Thanks, We have confirmed the bug in X110 Received Responses for All On and All off codes

This has been posted to the X10 forum for easy reference http://www.comfortforums.com/view_topic.php?id=4194&forum_id=33

[mikeinnc]

Thanks for confirmation. I\'ll look forward to the firmware update.

[eborges]

I thik it would be a good addition to Comfigurator the possibility of using  Do While or For /Next constructs.
 They are a basic feature that can be found in any programing language.

I would certainly make use of them.

[slychiu]

Please check out ULT 7074 beta http://www.comfortforums.com/forum33/4194.html which fixes the x10 all on/off received response

[mikeinnc]

Well, of course, I entirely agree with you! I find it amazing that a \'programmable\' system that has the \'microcode\' ability to support this construct doesn\'t have it at the \'higher language\' level. Let\'s hope we get some more support from others to get this adopted.

Meanwhile, I have worked out a way to do this using 3 responses. In my specific case, I want to flash some lights three times. I have three responses which we will call Response1; Response2 and Response3.


Response1:
If NightTime <> 0 Then    If Counter Counter013 <> 0 Then !CBus Grp 13         Set Counter051 = 3        Do Response2    End If  End If


Response2:
Cbus2 UCM02 13 25 121  Wait 3 Seconds Using Timer25  Cbus2 UCM02 13 25 1  Wait 3 Seconds Using Timer25  Decrement Counter051  Do Response3


Response3:
If Counter Counter051 <> 0 Then Do Response2   End If

It works - but it is \"messy\" and we shouldn\'t have to go to this level!